| CLEANER
PRODUCTION OPTIONS FOR PULP AND PAPER INDUSTRY |
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROBLEMS AND CLEANER PRODUCTION OPTIONS :
The
socio-economic importance of paper has its own value to the country's development
at it is directly related to the industrial and economic growth of the country.
The per capital consumption in India is 2.5 kg. per year, while the Asian average
itself is 18 kg. At present in our country, the 380 pulps and paper industries
have an aggregate capacity of 3.95 million tones.
Looking into the serious
nature of pollution, the pulp and paper industry in India has been brought under
the 17 categories of highly polluting industries. The paper industries, under
this category having capacity above 30 tonnes per day, are 96 in number. Out of
these, 62 units have the required facilities to comply with the effluent/emission
standards while 19 units do not have adequate treatment facilities. 15 units have
been closed down.
The small units using agro-residue as a raw material
are a threat to the environment. In India, the total installed capacity of small
pulp and paper industry is about 1.95 million tones per year. These units discharge
the black liquor along with unrecovered chemicals, which is difficult to treat
since lignin in the black liquor is not easily biodegradable. The presence of
caustic in black liquor results in increase in dissolved solids in wastewater
streams. The sodium concentration renders sodium toxicity if the effluent is discharged
on soil for irrigation. The discharge of untreated black liquor also results in
the loss of valuable chemicals. It has been estimated that discharge from a 30
tonnes per day agro-based paper mill is equivalent to the pollution load from
a 100 tonnes per day mill with chemical recovery. The major problem is the lack
of economically feasible methods of chemical recovery from the black liquor of
the small pulp and paper mills.
The presence of silica and small fibers
make the task of recovery difficult. Another problem is low concentration of the
black liquor from the agricultural residues. The agro-based paper mill should
either upgrade the scale of operation for the economic affordability of the process
or for the clusters of such mills a mother pulping and common chemical recovery
plant should be set up on lines of the common effluent treatment plants. The Hindustan
Newsprint Limited, Kerala, has developed the process of desilication, to remove
silica, through selective precipitation and carbonization. The black liquor from
rice straw may contain 11-14% of silica as dry mass, while that of wheat straw
contains 4-8% . The Uttar Pradesh based M/s Amrit Papers Limited, has also developed
a chemical recovery technology, best suited for bamboo, bagasse, and straw and
reeds-based paper mills. In the process, black liquor is concentrated and then
mixed with solid fuel and precipitated sludge. It is burnt to a semi-solid mass,
which is leached and as a result green liquor is formed. It is later carbonized
to precipitate the silica. This silica is of high purity and may be used for other
purposes. This process has been successfully displayed on a pilot scale, but its
economy for small-scale agro-based paper mill is still to be assessed.
Direct alkali recovery system has been developed by the Central Pulp & Paper Research
Institute (CPPRI). The process involves combustion of semi-concentrated soda black
liquor admixed with ferric oxide in a fluidized bed boiler. The sodium ferrite
granules are further hydrolyzed for the recovery of sodium hydroxide and ferric
oxide. The ferric oxide is used again in the fluidized bed boiler. This process
is yet to be tried in small paper mills.
By adopting the cleaner pulping
process, the generation of black liquor can be restricted. An attempt in this
direction has been made by M/s Pudumjee Pulp & Paper Mills Limited, Pune, by developing
and operating clcohol-based pulping. The process is still in the pilot scale.
In this process, after pulping of the agro-residues, the solvent is recovered
through distillation and pure lignin is recovered as a byproduct. Most agro-based
pulp & paper industries belong to small sector, producing as low as 5 tonnes per
year of paper. The installation of the chemical recovery system is difficult for
them due to high initial cost and a prolonged payback system. The concept of the
common chemical recovery can be a solution for such industries situated in a cluster.
The black liquor can be suitably collected from each of the units and processed
at common chemical recovery plant. There are at least four such sites in the country
having number of paper industries in the vicinity.
Traditionally, the
bleaching of pulp is performed with the help of elemental chlorine. The bleaching
is essential for the improvement in brightness, cleanliness and removing impurities.
The advantages of chlorination are that it is most effective delignifying agent
and at the same time least expensive of all the bleaching chemicals. It is also
excellent for the shive and dirt removal. But, in the recent years, chlorine is
viewed as enemy of the environment, as it destroys the stratospheric ozone layer,
and produces dioxin and organic chlorides. Its low consistency produces a large
volume of acidic effluent, which has to be neutralized before waste treatment.
It degrades pulp to some extent and is corrosive in nature.
These days,
chlorine is gradually being replaced with several other chemicals, such as chlorine
dioxide, oxygen, ozone and hydrogen peroxide. Oxygen was first applied successful
for bleaching of dissolved pulp by Russian scientists, V M Nikitin and GL Akin,
in the fifties. Since installation of the first oxygen- bleaching plant in South
Africa in 1969, this technology found its importance, as reflected by over 12,000
tonne per day of oxygen bleached pulp production per day worldwide. While reducing
the pollution load remains the incentive for the first oxygen-bleach plant, later
on, other benefits such as lower operating costs and savings of bleach chemicals
in subsequent stages, can be realized. Moreover, oxygen is non-toxic and non-corrosive.
The only disadvantage with this system is that it needs high temperature and pressure,
and increases load to recovery system. In the oxygen bleaching, in addition to
delignification, significant brightness is also gained, while in chlorination
there is no improvement in pulp brightness.
The use of chloride dioxide
as bleaching agent assures very high and stable brightness. It is best for shive
and dirt removal, and is highly selective in nature, for which there is little
degradation to pulp. It produces less organic chlorine than either chlorine or
chlorates. The problems associated with the use of chlorine dioxide is that it
is highly explosive, corrosive and toxic. There is possibility to use hypo chlorite
for bleaching in the pulp mills, which is less expensive than chlorine dioxide,
and also good for shive and dirt removal. It is easy to generate and handle. The
disadvantages with hypo chlorite is that if proper pH of the medium is not maintained,
it causes severe degradation to pulp, and during the process, chloroform, a toxic
gas, is produced. Now a day, hydrogen peroxide and ozone is also used for bleaching.
For a better result, many industries use a controlled sequence of chlorination,
alkaline extraction, chlorine dioxide, oxygen, hypo chlorite, peroxide and ozone
treatment for the pulp bleaching.
Pollution
Prevention Opportunities in Pulp Bleaching
- Installing
chemical controls to optimize chemical consumption and to minimize chlorinated
compounds formation;
- Installation
of advanced chemical mixing equipment to optimize the chemical consumption;
- Chlorine
dioxide substitution to reduce molecular chlorine consumption and formation of
chlorinated compounds;
- Enhanced
extraction to improve caustic extraction and improve delignification;
- Replacement
of hypo chlorite with chlorine dioxide to reduce chloroform formation significantly;
- Ozone
bleaching to eliminate chlorine-bearing chemical consumption; and
- Managing
the washing sequence to reduce bleach plant wastewater flow and water and energy
consumption
|
Ever-rising
energy costs and unrelenting environmental pressures are going to govern not only
the bleaching technology but also the course of all other technologies in future.
The cost of chlorine and chlorine-based chemicals, the main bleaching chemicals,
depends more on the energy cost as compared to oxygen. Also, the chlorine-based
chemicals are mainly responsible for the formation of pollutants, in particular
of toxic compounds. These two factors tilt the balance in favour of oxygen and
its derivatives as the bleaching chemicals of tomorrow. Mixing of oxygen into
the extraction stage of existing bleach plants (Eostage) is already practiced
by many European and North Americal pulp mills. It is claimed that use of an Eostage
can reduce the stages in a bleach plant by one, without sacrificing the pulp quality
and with significant savings in operating costs. This approach represents a low-cost
alternative to significantly reduce the discharge of the pollutants. Besides oxygen
and hydrogen peroxide bleaching, which are well-established techniques, ozone
delignification and bleaching are also in the developmental stage.
The
paper machines usually employed in the small-scale industries are getting outdated.
Productivity-linked approach is being adopted by improving the efficiency of the
existing machines and by installing machines of higher capacity with more automation.
The new efficient machines save energy and reduce the overall pollution load.
The effluent from paper mill section is rich in chemicals and fibers, which can
be used in the process. Small-scale paper units either do not have fiber-recovery
system or have a low efficiency one. The use of floatation-based units, which
clarify the effluent in a better way, recover the suspended fibers more efficiently
while simultaneously showing an efficiency range in excess of 90 per cent has
been proved to be beneficial. The clarified water can be used for the process,
for dilution and for cleaning.
Improved house-keeping, adoption of better
pollution abatement technology, development of recycling system and recovery of
useful products from waste, and proper training of concerned persons, will certainly
help the pulp and paper industry to maintain a cleaner environment.